Search This Blog

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

Two things for the Cleveland Indians to do (not that they listen to me, but ...)

I suppose I am not the only one with an opinion about what the Cleveland Indians should so for next season, but here are my two most major thoughts:

1. Victor Martinez should move to first base. The Indians have no one better than he is at first. Moving there from catcher also will save wear and tear on his body. Based on the way he hit this year, I think we can conclude that Ryan Garko is not an everyday player. He may be excellent as a complimentary guy who plays a few times a week, though. On top of this, I think Kelly Shoppach, in the absence of Martinez, has shown he can catch every day and do a pretty good job with the glove, arm and the bat. I think the Indians are better off with Martinez and Shoppach in the lineup than with Martinez and Garko.

2. Jhonny Peralta should move to third. The Indians don't have a better third baseman. It has become painfully obvious that Andy Marte isn't going to get it done offensively or defensively. Besides, Peralta is at best average defensively at short and may be better suited for third base in the long term. On the other hand, Asdrubal Cabrera, who would replace Peralta, is an outstanding defensive shortstop, and may turn out to be a better than average hitter for the position.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

how about garko returning to catching as well as a dual backup.